Monday, January 21, 2008

Thoughts on Universal Healthcare

The health of a human being. It is a paramount essence to ones' livelihood. The very thing that keeps a person alive and judges a persons' odds of living into tomorrow, next week, next month, or even next year. Our health is based on our heart, lungs, bone strength, and muscle strength among other factors. The proper maintenance of the factors of overall health is a top importance to anyone if they want to live a long life. A person alone, however, can not check how his or her heart is working and whether it needs to be examined. A person alone can not check their own teeth to see if they need fillings or a root canal. A person alone can not perform surgery on themselves to repair a torn ACL. This is why we have doctors, dentists, surgeons, and many other medical professionals. We visit them to get our check-up. We visit them when something in our body goes wrong. However, they, lust like anyone who has a job, needs to be paid. The bills are usually paid by the patient. The bills can be expensive, sometimes costing as much as a thousand dollars. Luckily, we have insurance that can co-pay the fees and bills.

Sadly insurance companies at times do not co-pay for operations. It is a depressing fact, but many who do not have good insurance and can not afford for surgeries that can save a person's life do not get the mandated treatment. They are turned away from the help they need. They are denied of the care that they mandate. Instead of having a doctor to take care of them, those who could not get the care they need to save their lives because of a bad insurance policy are left for dead. This is a sad dose of reality. It is heartbreaking to hear the stories of those who lost loved ones because some insurance companies are too cheap to co-pay for a surgery that could have saved their lives. This is a serious problem in this nation and it is a topic in the presidential campaign. A solution is needed.

The easiest solution and the one favored by the democratic presidential candidates is universal, or socialized, healthcare. Universal healthcare is a program used in Canada, England, and France among other countries that guarantees everyone healthcare regardless of insurance. The idea of universal healthcare in America sounds like a great solution. All of those who were turned away from healthcare because of affordability will get the healthcare because it is paid for by the government. That sounds like a good idea, doesn't it? Our government pays for the police force and for the fire department. They also pay for the roads and their maintenance. Imagine if we had to pay for our police force or for the fire department. I tremble at the thought of the people not getting help from law enforcement because they could not pay for it. I wince at the thought of not getting help from the fire department because I could not pay them. If we do not have to pay for the police or fire departments, then why should we have to pay for healthcare. Universal healthcare is a fabulous idea...

...on paper.

Universal healthcare is not the best solution. In fact, it is far from the best solution. One of the flaws of universal healthcare are waiting lists. Those on the list have to wait several days or even months to get the treatment they need. They can not move ahead regardless of the severity of their condition. They have to wait some time in order to get the treatment they need. Imagine that you need a surgery as soon as possible, but you are put on a waiting list. You could wait for months, not getting the care you need while your condition worsens. You could even die while you are waiting for your operation. Even if the average waiting time is only a couple of days, a day or two could be the difference between life or death. This flaw is worsened by those who would go to the doctor when even the littlest thing in them goes wrong. Those who do that clog up the lists and holds up those who are in more need of medical care than those who may have nothing worse than a runny nose or morning sickness (the feeling you get when you wake up and quickly goes away).

Universal healthcare has other flaws, but none of which are as paramount as this. Earlier in this commentary, I noted that the police department, the fire department, and our roads are paid for by the government. Where does this money come from? It comes from...OUR TAXES. Those who claim that universal healthcare is free could not be further from the truth. The government uses our tax dollars to pay for law enforcement, our firemen, and our military among other things. Imagine your tax dollars going to a person who sees a doctor over nothing worse than a cough, or a person who sees a doctor to get a prescription for medicine to make meth, or even to those who commit fraud. The thought of those who abuse something that is paid by our taxes is sick, but those who would commit fraud with our tax dollars is beyond sick. It is repugnant. This can happen and possibly will happen with a universal healthcare system. This is a society that cares for others, but it is not selfish to think to yourself sometimes. The higher tax rates that come with universal healthcare will leave you with less money for the things you need. You will have less money for your home, your groceries, running water, electricity, and other essentials. Low-income families will be under a heavier burden with the higher tax rates and homeless rates could increase. Universal healthcare is paid by tax dollars. It is not free.

Backers of universal healthcare accuse hospitals of denying care to those who enter emergengy rooms if they can not pay for it. This is not only false, it is illegal. Federal law obligates emergency rooms to care for those who need it regardless of affordability.

The healthcare system in this nation is broken, but a universal healthcare system is not the answer. The waiting list will have patients needing an immediate surgery waiting either a day or half a year and taxes will sharply increase. In fact, nations that have socialized healthcare have higher tax rates than the U.S. France has a tax rate six times the rate in this country. Universal healthcare sounds good on paper, but it may not work in the United States.

Good night and good luck.

No comments: